facebook| twitter|  russian| Phone Search:
  • RSS
Samsung Galaxy Note. First Look

Today, large companies, especially corporate giants like Samsung, do not surprise users with extraordinary products...

First look. Sony ST21i Tapioca Microsoft Windows Phone 7: Reasons for Failure First Look at Samsung Galaxy S3 as a 2012 Flagship
Reviews Editorials


Rambler's Top100

Toshiba e800: the outlook for the PocketPC

Standard kit:

  • PDA
  • Docking station
  • Power supply adapter
  • CD with software
  • Users guide

It would have happened sooner or later. It was inevitable the matter being discussed much and even more written about in both rosy and skeptic tones - eventually IT has happened. But lets have a foreword first. A couple of years ago the PocketPC platform was leading in the PDA market with its high quality screens (a vivid color matrix, 240 by 320 pixels, relatively big diagonal, rich colors). At the same time handheld computers powered by PalmOS had an ever-square screen 160 by 160 pixels; and the Linux platform was a topic of interest only for specialists. Time flew, there appeared Sony CLIE models with color LCDs (480x320 pixels), by the end of 2002 Sharp amazed the public with its Zaurus C700 equipped with hardware keyboard and a large 640x480 pixel screen, being the best PDA for almost a year. Because of limitations applied by Microsoft to its own mobile operating system the Pocket PC made no headway. The notorious screen resolution affected the platform development and became the weak point: it turned useless to expand performance of CPU, video system and memory with such screen resolution as their stayed unclaimed. The appearance of the e800 from Toshiba marked the crucial point in the development process. The given model entered the market at the end of 2003 to guide the Pocket PC market, so that now one can easily imagine an average PPC in six months or a year. However that doesnt mean that Toshiba made the perfect handheld, it does suffer flaws. The Pocket PC platform succeeded in restoring its screen leadership. But lets not run ahead and review details step by step. Well resume the screen matter a little bit later.

Should the screen be even better we cant omit other components, including the casing. The latter is allied to the junior Toshiba model (the e400), we have reviewed it on the site before (now only in Russian). The same high quality blue plastic, austere style dominated by direct lines and unsmooth edges. However the side inserts made metallic-like (actually from plastic) slide in hands, thats disappointing. The junior model doesnt have that defect. Weve noticed another annoying factor, the shell actually drew fingerprints, and we have to clean it from time to time. The handheld is neither massive nor tiny (134,6x76,2x15,2) and weighs some 192 grams above the average. Strange, but that doesnt disturb the comfort device handling. It should be evident that it is hardly possible to have smaller dimensions with a 4 screen and two slots for expansion. To cut a long story short the handheld doesnt feel massive or awkward in hand (default expectations sounded controversial), it is comfortable to handle it, but wear it better in a case or on the belt; the e800 can be kept in the pocket pulling it down though.

Comfortable handling is achieved due to a proper dislocation of control buttons. The big navigation pad works in four or eight directions. You can change the mode in the settings.

By the way the 8-direction mode comes in handy while playing arcades. In the middle of the d-pad there is a tiny enter key. Despite its dimensions the key is hard to be missed. Four standard keys as though surround the d-pad. Besides the standard functions that keys are set for control functions in Windows Media Player (stop, pause, next track, screen toggle) and dully signed on the shell. You can also plug a handsfree (additionally obtained) to the PDA, and that two headset buttons bear default functions:

On the front panel there is a really loud speaker to the right, and the LED indicator to the left.

Control elements on the right side fit good to the left thumb: dictaphone button, jog wheel, hold button and IrDA in the bottom. The dictaphone makes acceptable records within short distances, but creates good impression. The jog wheel feels comfortable, does not stick and works clear. It is mostly used to browse e-books and does it perfect. The hold button prevents occasional key strokes, the function useful while listening to the music with the PDA uncovered (remember old Toshiba models with buttons sensitive to any event, now there is no reason for complaints). The IR location and the SIR (slow infrared) support do not make the port full-featured to remote control electric appliances. A flaw, but not serious one.

On top you will find two slots of extension, microphone, headphone jack, small Power button, LED indicator, stylus. Weve already mentioned the voice recording quality. Note, there is a common jack for stereo headphones and internal microphone. Given this the handheld has a special program for it, wait for the respective review part. A folding (telescopic) stylus has average dimensions and is easy to work with. When got untwisted the stylus can be used to reset the device or switch on/off the wireless adapter.

On the bottom you can see the power supply socket (you can charge the PDA without a cradle), USB port protected with a rubber gag, hard reset switch, on/off wireless adapter switch (enabled with an untwisted stylus as we mentioned). The back is taken up by the battery latch and the special hole for strap. However the device is too heavy to carry it on strap.

The docking station impressed much, even astonished. The bottom is made transparent and gets blue in the dark reflecting a blue circle. One thing for sure you should watch it. It attracts attention, but may disturb a quiet sleep. Speaking about cradle functionality it proved ultimate: the power supply socket, USB-host, USB cable fixed to the cradle for PC synchronization. Maximum functions to be mentioned at least.

Several words about CG Silicon or some lyrics Part 1

The gist suggests that Toshiba e800 is equipped with the best display for Pocket PCs nowadays. The diagonal is maximum 4, the resolution is also maximum 480x640 pixels. The screen is bright and viewed good indoors and outdoors. Sharp company is engaged in making screens for Toshiba PDAs.

If we examine companies developing and promoting LCD technologies we will find Sharp among the leaders. The company obtains most patents in that sphere. In the beginning of 2003 there were more than 500 patents, which accounted for 20% from the overall volume. Recently the company has offered an LCD supporting 3D (Sharp has established the consortium of software developers and electronic producers to promote the technology). Rumor has it that Sharp will release a billion colors LCD for the new Windows version! In other words no one should doubt the authority of Sharp concerning LCDs.

Sharp has dubbed its technology for mobile devices CG Silicon (Continuous Grain Silicon). Together with the OLED (organic light emitting diodes) technology the CG Silicon represents next generation displays for mobiles. However, the OLED was initially designed for external displays (but under hearsay Sony plans to issue Sony CLIE models with big OLED displays), and the CG Silicon thrived a year ago with Sharp Zaurus C700 and further models the C750 and C760 (but then the diagonal was only 3.7). In addition Sharp applies new type displays in other products: video cameras and mobile phones.

But whats that outstanding and advantageous about the CG Silicon technology? The main idea is to integrate into glass the digital algorithm (LCD driver, Input/Output interface, power stabilizer). In the result there is less elements, and the space is spared. The story began in the mid 90-s when two companies Sharp and Semiconductor Energy Laboratory built an 8-bit processor Z80 (released in 1976) into the glass substrate.

To continue success companies decided to develop the technology, thus the CG Silicon technology appeared in 1997. In theory, it is possible to integrate almost everything into the glass (processor, memory, system algorithm etc.), and the company claimed so in press releases. In the ideal circumstances the new technology allows to create a sheet computer or sheet TV. Well lets wait and see. Sheet computers do not to come soon, for now evident advantages of the CG Silicon are as follows.

The continuous grain grid (in this case a display corresponds with a big grain) allows to closely integrate control elements, but has by-effects. Firstly, the response time (electrons get through the grain grid faster than in analogues). Secondly, a surprisingly high resolution for small displays. Thirdly, dynamic resolution change. That is, by the program switch from 640x480 to 320x240 due the continuous grain grid the physical resolution also gets changed (not just the picture stretches). Besides it consumes less power. In the same manner the color depth is changed with corresponding power consumption. In practice we failed to prove the fact, lets trust the company.

The company managed a swift shift from prototypes and developments to the mass production of CG Silicon matrixes. In a year it can provide enough displays for almost everybody interested. There is a definite view on display production.

CG Silicon displays are made by two neighboring Sharp works. In October 2002 the Tenri Plant launched the production line with the capacity of 2,5 million units per month (for 2 matrixes), in June 2003 the Mie Plant started functioning: 4 million units per month (see the picture: it is to the left).

The matrix demand justified expectations. Sharp quickly sets about constructing the second line at the Mie Plant No.3 to satisfy a would-be high demand in future. See the table:

Hence, Sharp is to produce some 12 million units per month (2 matrixes) by the mid 2004, or 3 million units (4 matrixes), i.e. 36 million units per year. Even under the most favorable sales forecasts for 2004 the PDA market will hardly consume one sixth of that volume. It is evident that the lions sales share falls at handsets, smartphones, camcorders and cameras. At the steady raising of the production rate the average costs share (research and development/unit) falls, and displays get cheaper. OLED displays with 2-4 diagonal from other manufacturers will burst competition, and again displays get cheaper. The conclusion is that PDA makers wont suffer high resolution displays deficiency, besides the prices are ever-falling. This year PDAs with VGA displays (or higher) will boom. Here my lyrical story comes to the end. The display story to be continued in the paragraph software.

Off-line work

The handheld is equipped with a removable Li-Ion battery 1320 mAh. While testing the off-line work the PDA functioned well (however, the power consumption system is not well thought-out compared to Asus models). At the maximum load (maximum highlight, 400 MHz frequency, clips at high bit-rate) the handheld has worked 2 hours 40 minutes. In the mp3 mode (playing from a SD card, display off), but at the highest frequency (400 MHz) the e800 served 8 hours. Thus the display consumes most power. A continuous Bluetooth session lasted 5 hours (an active Internet connection through a handset, periodic PC synchronization, lame highlight, Power saving mode) a good figure. In an option you can use an enhanced battery (2640 mAh) to double off-line performance (note, it will affect dimensions and weight).

Some lyrics Part 2 or the Intel PXA 26x

On the processor market for stationary systems there is the main Intel processor development line to increase CPU index (MHz). As for mobile devices the key direction corresponds with optimal power consumption and smaller dimensions of the processor itself. The 2G processors XScale (PXA255) havent managed a record performance (the same 400 MHz), but power consumption decreased and speed burst due to the on-board bus speed of 200 MHz (from 100 MHz). Last year Intel presented the new line of PXA26x series. On paper it has the following advantages.

XScale PXA26x series (PXA261, PXA262, PXA263) processor is the first Intel processor based on the Multiple-Chip Product (MCP) technology. The MCP integrates lots of elements in a single chip: the processor, flash memory (Intel StrataFlash memory, 16-32 MB), LCD controller, Direct Memory Access, interface controllers including Bluetooth (doesnt it remind of the CG Silicon technology). The technology leads to tiny dimensions (13x13x1.4 mm for the PXA26x against 17x17x1.8 mm for PXA25x) and higher data transmitting speeds.There is detailed 150-page processor discretion on manufacturers site.

However, real tests do not reveal extra advantages. Quite on the contrary the processor stays firm in the middle. Some crucial changes may be noticed in the mid 2004 with Intel launching fundamentally new processor. Now lets pass to the real tests.

Productivity performance

There is the maximum RAM volume: 128 MB pretty good for today considering two memory extension slots. Even if you launch several programs simultaneously and install lots of programs into RAM the most of memory will stay unclaimed. To compare, in case with notebooks increased RAM to 512 MB or 1GB seems logical depending on operating system needs: speeds mount and off-line time extends as the swap-file is not required. Ive written much about the fact that Windows Mobile and respective programs do not require extra memory. Though its better to have much and not less. Flash memory (31 MB is available to the user) is recommended to be used for the backup and light programs. Lets test the CPU with the SPB Benchmark. For the test weve chosen PDAs equipped with two slots and with/without wireless adapters.

Integrated CPU index describes Pocket PCs CU speed. Well, the results have practically agreed. We werent surprised that the XScale PXA255 performed like the PXA263.

File system index describes PDA file system speed (read/write/move). Strange as it may seem but here the Toshiba leader has failed. The PXA263 differs from its rivals in the low power SDRAM support this could account for the results. The MiTAC also powered by a new processor delivers low results.

Platform index describes total PDA platform peed including the built-in applications. Thus we have another low results.

Integrated Spb Benchmark index describes total Pocket PC speed. The Toshiba e800 keeps satisfactory position, not low. This is enough for multi purposes, including 3D games and capacious applications. For some strange reasons weve failed to launch the PocketQuake game and wont provide related tests. Instead we examine the video mode. We started several test clips at different bitrate (DivX 5.03 codec). Sound got encoded in mp3 format with 128kbps bitrate. We applied the criteria of dropped frames while playing, the less the better and tested a fragment from the motion picture Cats and Dogs (the fight scene). See the results.

Though the e800 has the ATI graphic accelerator there is a weak point here: the external bus 100 MHz prevents better results. In case of the FSC LOOX 610 video is processed by the CPU (the on-board bus in the PXA263 and PXA255 runs at 200 MHz), that is why the e800 has lost. Unfortunately, mpeg4 files without an extra Toshiba processing wont properly play 640x480 resolution clips (a convincing fact to wait for another Intel processor). The overall performance agrees with other Pocket PCs without surprises or disappointments.

Interface

The e800 enjoys the maximum interfaces. Lets begin with wire ones. Advanced users will like two slots for expansion. The SD/MMS is meant for memory cards and the CF for peripherals, for example the CF GPS or CF Bluetooth adapter. However you can plug peripherals to the SD slot and insert 1 GB card into the CF.

The standard USB-host is set in the docking station. So you can plug a hard drive, mouse, keypad, flash storage and some other devices. The problem to face is the availability of special drivers (before buying a device make sure it has Pocket PC drivers). Enthusiasts solder cables by themselves to plug USB through the modified cable. The same for the COM-port. In addition you can acquire the Presentation Pack jack. Its the RGB port for mobile and video presentations.

Now to the wireless networking, a more interesting part. There are two versions available: the Wi-Fi (IEEE 802.11b) for the USA and the Bluetooth version for Europe. In Europe the Wi-Fi interface just starts gaining popularity. Weve tested the Bluetooth model. In spite of the fact that the company designed the Bluetooth software by itself, the software displayed a steady work with other devices and proved easy to tune. Tests revealed no reprimands concerning networking via a handset, PC synchronization, SMS. Both versions support the Bluetooth-chat. You can get access to main Bluetooth functions though programs:

ActiveSync settings have pleased us: you can set networking in and for a certain period, during which the ActiveSync connection will be enabled. We should mark the high synchronization speed. It felt like for HP iPAQ.

You can get synchronized with a PC, get access to folders (the FTP profile), set networking or exchange contacts.

You can get connected to Internet via a mobile phone (tested with the Siemens S55), acquire melodies or logos (or visa versa download data from mobiles), exchange contacts or emulate the COM connection.

There were no problems with the HP iPAQ 1940. In general Bluetooth works good.

Part 2. Software>>>

Anton Kotov (anton.kotov@mobile-review.com)
Translated by Anja Rytchkova (anja.rytchkova@mobile-review.com)

Published - 12 February 2004

Have something to add?! Write us... eldar@mobile-review.com

 

News:

[ 31-07 16:21 ]Sir Jony Ive: Apple Isn't In It For The Money

[ 31-07 13:34 ]Video: Nokia Designer Interviews

[ 31-07 13:10 ]RIM To Layoff 3,000 More Employees

[ 30-07 20:59 ]Video: iPhone 5 Housing Shown Off

[ 30-07 19:12 ]Android Fortunes Decline In U.S.

[ 25-07 16:18 ]Why Apple Is Suing Samsung?

[ 25-07 15:53 ]A Few Choice Quotes About Apple ... By Samsung

[ 23-07 20:25 ]Russian iOS Hacker Calls It A Day

[ 23-07 17:40 ]Video: It's Still Not Out, But Galaxy Note 10.1 Gets An Ad

[ 19-07 19:10 ]Another Loss For Nokia: $1 Billion Down In Q2

[ 19-07 17:22 ]British Judge Orders Apple To Run Ads Saying Samsung Did Not Copy Them

[ 19-07 16:57 ]iPhone 5 To Feature Nano-SIM Cards

[ 18-07 14:20 ]What The iPad Could Have Looked Like ...

[ 18-07 13:25 ]App Store Hack Is Still Going Strong Despite Apple's Best Efforts

[ 13-07 12:34 ]Infographic: The (Hypothetical) Sale Of RIM

[ 13-07 11:10 ]Video: iPhone Hacker Makes In-App Purchases Free

[ 12-07 19:50 ]iPhone 5 Images Leak Again

[ 12-07 17:51 ]Android Takes 50%+ Of U.S. And Europe

[ 11-07 16:02 ]Apple Involved In 60% Of Patent Suits

[ 11-07 13:14 ]Video: Kindle Fire Gets A Jelly Bean

Subscribe

Register | Lost password?

E-mail


Password




Mobile-review.com, 2002-2012. All rights reserved.